Posted on Friday, February 12, 2021

Posted by Marylia Kelley

As you know Tri-Valley CAREs and colleague groups undertook numerous efforts during the Trump Administration to stop its proposal to expand plutonium “pit” (bomb core) production.

The productions sites chosen to churn out 80 or more pits per year are the Savannah River Site in South Carolina and the Los Alamos Lab in New Mexico. The plutonium pits to be produced are expressly for a novel warhead that California’s Livermore Lab is developing, called the W87-1.

Today’s blog brings you new information on our campaign.

One prong of our campaign is to force the National Nuclear Security Administration to comply with the National Environmental Policy Act, which requires that the agency undertake a Programmatic Environmental Impact Statement (PEIS) before proceeding with expanded pit production at two locations.

In this endeavor, we are particularly happy to announce a new association with the much-respected South Carolina Environmental Law Project (SCELP). The three groups retaining the firm are Tri-Valley CAREs, Nuclear Watch New Mexico and Savannah River Site Watch. Here, for your reading pleasure, is our – and SCELP’s – opening salvo to the new Biden Administration asking them to review and reject decisions made by the Trump team.

FIRST, here is a link to today’s news release on the pit issue…

“Biden Administration Asked to Review Plutonium Pit Expansion Plans” Our new legal counsel at SCELP posts it at

You can also find a copy on our website at

SECOND, I am pleased to say that one prominent news organization has already published a story. More articles are expected to follow…

The State (in Columbia, So. Carolina)

“Atomic weapons plan risky for SC, lawyers say. Noted legal service joins fray” By Sammy Fretwell, February 12, 2021

A South Carolina legal service has joined the fight against an atomic weapons components factory at the Savannah River Site, raising the possibility that environmental groups will sue the federal government to stop the effort.

The South Carolina Environmental Law Project, a non-profit service with an extensive court record, outlined concerns about the factory in a letter this week to the U.S.

Department of Energy. The letter called the proposed factory risky and in need of further study.

At issue is a proposal to build a nuclear weapons pit plant that would use plutonium, a deadly long-lived radioactive material, at the Savannah River Site.

The pit factory would produce potentially thousands of jobs, but is drawing opposition from environmental groups in South Carolina, New Mexico and California.

Savannah River Site Watch, Nuclear Watch New Mexico and Tri-Valley CAREs recently retained the Environmental Law Project. They say pit factories are expensive, unnecessary, needlessly threaten the environment, and could leave unused plutonium stranded in South Carolina and New Mexico.

President Joe Biden’s administration needs to be “aware of the serious environmental and human health risks associated with a significant expansion in pit production,’’ according to a letter written Wednesday by law project attorney Leslie Lenhardt to the energy department.

Nearly a dozen key members of Congress were copied on the letter, including Republican senators Lindsey Graham and Tim Scott of South Carolina and Sen. Ben Ray Lujan, D-New Mexico.

Plans call for producing 50 pits a year at SRS on the site of a failed mixed oxide fuel plant near Aiken not far from the Georgia border. Another 30 pits would be produced each year at the U.S. Department of Energy’s Los Alamos, N.M., site.

The government says the factories would provide fresh pits to replace the aging ones now used in nuclear weapons, while also providing the stockpile to produce a new type of atomic weapon. Boosters say pit factories are vital to the nation’s defense, although not everyone agrees.

Opponents are asking the government to conduct an extensive study, called a programmatic environmental impact statement, before moving ahead with the effort. Such a study would be more comprehensive than past studies, likely delaying the pit production effort. They are concerned that more than 7 tons of plutonium could be brought to SRS after the state negotiated a deal to rid the site of stranded plutonium.

No decision has been made on whether to file suit because opponents of the pit factories hope the Biden administration will reverse course and scrap the long-discussed proposal. Plans to build the SRS pit factory, on the table since the 1990s, resurfaced while President Donald Trump was in office.

“We would like to avoid a lawsuit, so now the door is open to negotiation with DOE,’’ said Tom Clements, who heads Savannah River Site Watch. “I hope they will step through that door and talk to us.”

If not, filing a lawsuit “remains on the table,’’ Clements said.

Lenhardt’s letter said the groups are “hopeful that you will seek to review the former administration’s failure’ to conduct’’ the comprehensive environmental impact statement.

The S.C. Environmental Law Project has taken on some of the highest profile environmental cases in the state since Pawleys Island attorney Jimmy Chandler founded the service in 1987.

Through the years, the law project has handled a variety of cases, including numerous lawsuits to protect coastal wetlands and beaches from over development. But it also has been involved in suits against Barnwell County’s nuclear waste dump, a disposal site at the Savannah River Site, garbage landfills across South Carolina and a hazardous waste incinerator in York County.

One of its most high profile cases was a successful effort to close a hazardous waste landfill on Lake Marion.

Until the Southern Environmental Law Center opened an office in Charleston, the Environmental Law Project was the only non-profit legal service of its kind in South Carolina.


-end of article-

Dear friends, stay tuned! We will alert you as developments continue to unfold on this important topic – and on our other programs too.

And, don’t forget to join our Tri-Valley CAREs February meeting on Thursday the 18th at 7:30pm. Our flyer and zoom link follow…

HAGA CLIC AQUÍ para leer la información en español